What would be the right empathetic view in the pin-cushion episode?
Answer and explanation
Correct answer: Understanding Kezia's loving intention along with her mistake
An empathetic judgement considers both the result of an action and the intention behind it. Kezia did cause real damage by tearing her father’s speech papers, so empathy does not require pretending that no mistake occurred. However, she was trying to make a pin-cushion as a loving gift and did not understand the value of the papers. Option B is correct because it balances accountability with compassion. Focusing only on the damaged papers would produce an incomplete and harsh judgement. Grandmother suggested that Kezia make something, but she was not responsible for Kezia choosing the papers, so blaming her entirely is unfair. Macdonald had no role in the incident. The story therefore teaches that understanding motive can make correction wiser and relationships more humane.
Frequently asked questions
What is the correct answer to this question?
Understanding Kezia's loving intention along with her mistake
Why is this the correct answer?
An empathetic judgement considers both the result of an action and the intention behind it. Kezia did cause real damage by tearing her father’s speech papers, so empathy does not require pretending that no mistake occurred. However, she was trying to make a pin-cushion as a loving gift and did not understand the value of the papers. Option B is correct because it balances accountability with compassion. Focusing only on the damaged papers would produce an incomplete and harsh judgement. Grandmother suggested that Kezia make something, but she was not responsible for Kezia choosing the papers, so blaming her entirely is unfair. Macdonald had no role in the incident. The story therefore teaches that understanding motive can make correction wiser and relationships more humane.
Which subject and chapter does this question cover?
This is a Class 9 English question. Chapter: The Little Girl. Topic: empathy.
Student feedback
Was this question useful?
👍 0 Helpful 👎 0 Not helpful
Yes 0% No 0%
0 responsesStudent Reviews
No published reviews yet.
