When an employee has to express a view but disagrees with a senior, which behaviour is most balanced?
Answer and explanation
Correct answer: Present facts and a respectful alternative suggestion
Balanced disagreement means expressing a different view without being rude, hostile or passive. An employee can respect a senior person while still presenting evidence and explaining another possible solution. This is a form of assertive communication because the speaker is clear about the idea but also considerate toward others. Therefore, option C is correct. Staying silent and resentful does not communicate constructively, harsh opposition damages cooperation, and leaving the meeting avoids the issue rather than solving it.
The important combination is facts, respect and an alternative suggestion. Facts make the disagreement more objective, while respectful language keeps the discussion professional. Offering another solution also shows that the employee is trying to improve the work, not merely criticize a decision. A senior’s position does not mean every suggestion must be accepted, but disagreement should be expressed responsibly. Thus, presenting facts and a respectful alternative is the most balanced behaviour and clearly supports option C.
Frequently asked questions
What is the correct answer to this question?
Present facts and a respectful alternative suggestion
Why is this the correct answer?
Balanced disagreement means expressing a different view without being rude, hostile or passive. An employee can respect a senior person while still presenting evidence and explaining another possible solution. This is a form of assertive communication because the speaker is clear about the idea but also considerate toward others. Therefore, option C is correct. Staying silent and resentful does not communicate constructively, harsh opposition damages cooperation, and leaving the meeting avoids the issue rather than solving it.
The important combination is facts, respect and an alternative suggestion. Facts make the disagreement more objective, while respectful language keeps the discussion professional. Offering another solution also shows that the employee is trying to improve the work, not merely criticize a decision. A senior’s position does not mean every suggestion must be accepted, but disagreement should be expressed responsibly. Thus, presenting facts and a respectful alternative is the most balanced behaviour and clearly supports option C.
Which subject and chapter does this question cover?
This is a Class 11 Home Science question. Chapter: Work, Livelihood and Career. Topic: Essential soft skills at workplace.
