During a group discussion, a student says, “Your idea is useless.” Which statement is most appropriate for expressing the same disagreement constructively?
Answer and explanation
Correct answer: I disagree with your idea because it does not include a cost estimate; can we add one?
Option A separates the person from the idea, identifies a specific and correctable weakness, and invites collaboration on an improvement. The other statements attack the person, silence participation, or make an unsupported absolute judgement. Constructive disagreement should be specific, respectful, and open to further discussion.
Frequently asked questions
What is the correct answer to this question?
I disagree with your idea because it does not include a cost estimate; can we add one?
Why is this the correct answer?
Option A separates the person from the idea, identifies a specific and correctable weakness, and invites collaboration on an improvement. The other statements attack the person, silence participation, or make an unsupported absolute judgement. Constructive disagreement should be specific, respectful, and open to further discussion.
Which subject and chapter does this question cover?
This is a Class 11 English question. Chapter: Father to Son. Topic: Communication Problems.
