What is the main macroeconomic error in directly treating individual saving as total saving of the economy?
The paradox of thrift shows that saving is sensible for an individual, but if all households simultaneously reduce consumption, aggregate demand may fall. Lower demand can reduce firms’ sales, production, employment and incomes, potentially lowering total saving despite the intention to save more. This fallacy of composition is why individual and macroeconomic effects must be distinguished. Thus, A is correct.